There is a bug in Windows Server 2008 R2 causing a "Bad DNS Packet" error when you try to setup (or promote) Active Directory using Simple DNS Plus and other non-MS DNS servers.
The problem is described in MS KB 977158 - see http://support.microsoft.com/kb/977158/EN-US
The solution is to install the mentioned Windows hotfix.
However the MS KB article only links to the IA64 version of the hotfix - not the X64 version which most people need.
You can get a copy of the X64 version from https://simpledns.plus/outbox/KB977158-x64.zip
Note that this hotfix will likely be included in a future automatic Windows update and/or a service pack.
So this temporary solution will only be necessary until then.
For more information on using Simple DNS Plus with Active Directory, click here
Trouble logging in? Simply enter your email address OR username in order to reset your password.
For faster and more reliable delivery, add firstname.lastname@example.org to your trusted senders list in your email software.